Two households, both alike in dignity,
       In fair Verona, where we lay our scene,
       From ancient grudge break to new mutiny,
       Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.

 

In a Heart Unique
by Lisa Binkley

The patient, a 50-year-old white male, lay on the gurney, no longer struggling for each full breath. The attending physician, a doctor with many years of experience and additional training specializing in emergency medicine, listened to the summary that the paramedic provided. He didn't take notes - that being someone else's responsibility - but began his preliminary assessment as a nurse replaced the blood pressure cuff with an automatic one.

"Twelve lead?" she asked, preparing to page the technician. Another nurse switched the air supply from the portable oxygen to a port in the wall. The shriveled bag of saline solution was removed and another hung on the metal pole.

After complaining throughout the morning about indigestion and a sore left shoulder, the business executive had been found gasping from pain and clutching his chest in his office after lunch by his partner. He confessed feeling a huge pressure in his upper body. The secretary dialed 911 while the colleague hovered nearby in case CPR was needed.

"Coronary profile and a chest x-ray," the doctor ordered, and then moved on to the occupant of the next cubicle to await the test results. The battery would rule out anemia, liver damage, kidney insufficiencies, diabetes, and measure various heart-related enzymes, such as creatine kinase (CK), ultra-sensitive cardiac C-reactive protein, myoglobin, and troponin while the x-ray ruled out lung disease as the source of dyspnea (labored breathing).

Mr. Jones's secretary had supplied the name of his general practitioner, who was located in the suburb were the patient lived.

A phone call to that office generated a faxed copy of the most recent medical history including a previous EKG. The tracing showed changes signifying myocardial infarction. The strips of heat-sensitive paper were photocopied and the copy entered into Mr. Jones's growing chart.

Based on the patient's history, symptoms, and test results, he was admitted to the Coronary Care Unit (CCU) and placed under the care of a cardiologist. Reperfusion therapy (drugs that prevent muscle damage in the heart due to clots), which had been initiated earlier, was continued.

A cardiac catherization revealed occlusion (blocked arteries) so an angioplasty followed to reopen the vessels. A stent, a tiny mesh tube positioned at the site of the blockage, would insure greater success of the procedure. After surgery, Mr. Jones was counseled on weight management, maintaining lower cholesterol, stress-reduction techniques, and the benefits of regular exercise.

He took the advice to heart and enrolled in cardiac rehab, water aerobics, and enlisted the help of his worried family to stick to his new diet.

In advance of a regular follow-up visit a few years later, the cardiologist recommended an exercise stress test. While walking on the treadmill, Mr. Jones complained of difficulty breathing, which prematurely terminated the procedure. The special pictures detected another partial blockage. Another cath and angioplasty restored the blood flow.

Mr. Jones was tested for homocysteine deficiency and instructed to add folic acid and B12 vitamins as a precaution against further plaque build-up.

Between life-style changes, dietary improvement, exercise program, stress awareness, and specific medical attention to his ongoing cardiac status, Mr. Jones had an excellent chance at maintaining quality and expectancy of life.

The patient, a 50-year-old over-weight black female, lay on the gurney, struggling for each full breath. The attending physician, a resident exhausted from his too many hours of on-call, listened to the summary that the paramedic provided. He didn't take notes - assuming the ambulance report was complete - but began his assessment as an aide replaced the blood pressure cuff with an automatic one.

"Twelve-lead?" she asked. Only the week before an administrator had issued a memo about the volume of unnecessary procedures performed on noninsured patients and how these unpaid accounts influenced the hospital's already precarious financial status.

The resident nodded. As it turned out, the tracings were unremarkable and, without a previous sample to compare, not particularly helpful.

The aide switched the oxygen supply from the portable canister to a port in the wall. The bag of saline solution was removed and another hung on the metal pole.

The woman had fainted while working as a grocery cashier. Her customer had used a cell phone to call 911, while the manager tried to maintain calm among the employees and other patrons.

"Metabolic panel, CBCs and 'lytes" the doctor ordered, and then moved on to the occupant of the next cubicle to await the test results. The battery would rule out anemia, liver damage, kidney insufficiencies, and diabetes.

The supermarket had an emergency contact number, and Mrs. Smith's daughter supplied the name of the clinic where her mother sought medical care on the infrequent occasions when an aspirin didn't help. The clerk groaned, "Not the Clinic!" and started a series of phone calls for the chart that, eventually, revealed a sketchy history of possible diabetes and untreated hypertension.

Based on the patient's history, symptoms, and test results, she was admitted to a Med/Surg unit where, the next day, she was counseled on sugar management, dietary restrictions, and medication changes, before being discharged with instructions to follow-up with the clinic.

Mrs. Smith, a busy woman with children and grandchildren relying on her, lost a few pounds, took her blood pressure medicines when she remembered, and had her glucose checked once in a while.

Several months later, having felt tired and short of breath since her previous admission, Mrs. Smith passed out in her kitchen and appeared to stop breathing.

The paramedics found an irregular heart rhythm and, after numerous attempts with a portable defibrillator, were able to resuscitate her. They transported the victim to the closest ER, where cardiac enzymes were performed and discovered to be extremely elevated.

Mrs. Smith died prior to admission; the fresh infarction inflicting irreparable damage to her already scarred heart. An autopsy revealed blockages and evidence of earlier significant heart disease.

Mrs. Smith's resident, now in his cardiac rotation, reviewed the chart and wondered why he hadn't tested for cardiac involvement even though Mrs. Smith hadn't presented with classic symptoms or a positive EKG. With all her risk factors, he would have been justified to do additional tests, regardless of her uninsured status.

Between life-style changes, dietary improvement, exercise program, stress awareness, and specific attention to lowering her cardiac risk, Mrs. Smith could have had a better chance to survive.

In the medical community, there appears to exist an underlying conspiracy of racial and gender basis. Survival rates post coronary event are slightly lower for black and female victims than for white males, with an especially significant higher mortality rate for young black females.

The fact that medicine, which should be the bastion of color and gender equality, falls short for any member of our society has been studied to better understand the dynamics of the failure and separate prejudice from other contributing factors. Outright malpractice is not the problem in most cases. Instead, several subtler mechanisms seem to be operating.

Access to medical facilities is dependant on financial status, regional availability, and the patient's insurance company preferences. Delaying or forgoing treatment while waiting for referrals or the next paycheck can negatively impact the prognosis.

While public health alerts appear to reach the more economically fortunate in society, who have altered life-styles to include weight, cholesterol, and stress management, smoking cessation, and the benefits of aerobic fitness, the messages are not making the same impact on the underprivileged. Interestingly, poor families who have maintained a traditional ethnic diet are less likely to suffer from cardiac disease.

Most research studies use healthy white males, with few preexisting medical conditions, to obtain data about new drugs, treatments, and effectiveness of diagnostic tools. The results are statistically significant, but have an obvious glaring error built in. The studies use healthy white males.

What can be said about healthy white males is only what can be applied to white males - not to white females, black males, black females, or any other group.

Coronary disease in men usually begins earlier than in women. Men typically exhibit a range of classically described symptoms, while women frequently have subtler signs that mimic other ailments.

Mr. Jones, in the example, has textbook symptoms. In addition, he has diagnostic changes in his EKG. As an additional benefit of his socio-economic status, he has a more thorough medical history.

At 50, Mrs. Smith is young for a heart attack. Hormones usually protect women until well past menopause. Her EKG is unremarkable - a common finding in blacks due to structural differences in the heart wall. EKGs are also more difficult to perform properly on the obese. Due to her financial condition, she hasn't sought out routine exams and has no comprehensive documentation of her medical history.

An experienced physician may have ordered cardiac marker tests on Mrs. Smith but, with negative EKG and no symptoms plus the positive history for under-treated diabetes and high blood pressure, he may have not have considered her fainting spell to be more than a side effect of one or the other.

Another problem in deciding whether medicine is neglecting some citizens is establishing the consequences of patient noncompliance. People resist medical care for a number of reasons, including the cost of medications and treatments, forgetfulness, denial, distrust of doctors, or misunderstanding of instructions due to language barrier or hearing disability.

Proper diagnosis of a patient requires a thorough risk history assessment, something many busy doctors may not do, relying instead on paramedic or nursing notes and the results of the EKG or blood tests. Unfortunately, the normal ranges these tests were established by the same studies that used white males as the study subjects. In some cases, only a patient's verbal history can support a doctor's decision to test further.

In recognition of the flaws in the current studies, more research organizations and drug companies are targeting the special problems of minority groups and women. These studies will take years to collect the body of data current available on white males.

In the meantime, all people need to be aware of the shortcomings of the present tools and insist on more thorough follow-up testing if the initial studies are inconclusive.

Compiling a family history can help determine if a genetic tendency exists for coronary disease. Keeping copies of results and interpretations, especially if one relocates frequently, can expedite diagnosis and treatment.

Inform the doctor or nurse if the victim has multiple risk factors. These include cigarette smoking, high blood pressure, high total cholesterol or LDL cholesterol, low HDL cholesterol, being overweight, having a sedentary life-style, and diabetes.

In a landmark project, the Nurses' Health Study polled over 84,000 women of all races and walks of life. Over a fourteen-year period, the researchers sent questionnaires to each woman every two years. The form inquired about weight, physical condition, smoking status, menopause, hormone usage, cholesterol, blood pressure, new medications, and other factors.

The single most beneficial thing a woman can do, in regards to the health of her heart, is stop smoking.

Meeting all five risk-lowering criteria (non-smoker, low body fat ratio, healthy diet, regular exercise, and a routine nightcap) can reduce the chance of heart attack by as much as 80%. Even two of these risk-lowering behaviors, in addition to not smoking, proved to be successful in lowering a woman's risk by 28%.

In a perfect society, everyone would have the same risks, the same treatment, and the same outcomes. In a society of unique individuals, where everyone has different risks, different treatments, and wildly variable outcomes, we all have identical responsibilities.

Manage our risks.

Take charge of our treatments.

Demand a positive outcome.

The key to avoiding or surviving a heart attack isn't in the hands of your doctor, or the hospital, or your insurance plan.

The key jingles in your own pocket.

Will you use it?

Symptoms of Heart Attack

Lethargy and/or generalized weakness

Shortness of breath, cough, and/or difficulty breathing

Discomfort or pain in the neck, shoulder, jaw, or either arm

Nausea or indigestion with/without eating

Tightness, pressure, pain, or burning sensation in the chest

Sweating without exertion

 

The symptoms happen more often or more intensely during physical activity but can happen while resting.

Women often experience less severe chest pain, more nausea, and more weakness than men do.

If several of these indicators happen together or last for more than 10 minutes seek immediate medical attention.

References

  1. "Lady Killer," Suzanne Cambre, RN, BSHA for Pritchett & Hull Asc. Inc.

  2. "So You Have Heart Disease," NIH brochure

  3. "Reducing High Blood Cholesterol," NIH brochure

  4. "Are You At Risk?" NIH brochure

  5. Various articles from Colorado Health Site

  6. Blacks at Higher Risk for Death from Heart Failure, NIH news release

  7. Coronary Heart Disease Incidence and Survival in African American Women and Men, The Annals of Internal Medicine, July 15, 1997

  8. Prevalence of Coronary Heart Disease Risk Factors Among Rural Blacks, James P. Willems, etal, The Southern Medical Journal, August, 1997

  9. Differences in the Diagnosis Of Heart Disease in Women, Kansas City Infozine, from NPR Newswire, May, 1995

Copyright © 2002 Lisa J. Binkley
All rights reserved

 

About the Author


      Lisa Binkley works within the medical industry and is the popular author of this health series in the Kudzu Monthly. She serves as the fiction editor of this ezine and also edits for the online science fiction magazineDistant Worlds.
      Lisa maintains a website for her own original fiction and poetry called Jolie Howard Fiction.

      As Lisa phrases it, "Woman, wife, worker, writer. We all wear many faces and fill our niches as best we can."

* * * *

Reader's Comments

Kudzu Monthly urges all readers to provide feedback for the authors and editors of articles on this site. If you would like to comment on this article, you can enter your comments in the form below. They will be added to this page.

Your Name:
E-Mail:
(Optional)
Enter your comments in the box below
           

 


This is absolutely new approach to hypercholesterolemia treatment.

Dr. Dzugan


Med Hypotheses 2002 Nov;59(6):751-6 Related Articles, Links


Hypercholesterolemia treatment: a new hypothesis or just an accident?

Dzugan SA, Arnold Smith R.

North Central Mississippi Regional Cancer Center, Mississippi, Greenwood, USA

A new hypothesis concerning the association of low levels of steroid hormones and hypercholesterolemia is proposed. This study presents data that concurrent restoration to youthful levels of multiple normally found steroid hormones is able to normalize or improve serum total cholesterol (TC). We evaluated 20 patients with hypercholesterolemia who received hormonorestorative therapy (HT) with natural hormones. Hundred percent of patients responded. Mean serum TC was 263.5mg/dL before and 187.9mg/dL after treatment. Serum TC dropped below 200mg/dL in 60.0%. No morbidity or mortality related to HT was observed. In patients characterized by hypercholesterolemia and sub-youthful serum steroidal hormones, our findings support the hypothesis that hypercholesterolemia is a compensatory mechanism for life-cycle related down-regulation of steroid hormones, and that broadband steroid hormone restoration is associated with a substantial drop in serum TC in many patients.

Sergey A. Dzugan <sdzugan@tecinfo.com>
- Monday, May 05, 2003 at 12:07:22 (EDT)
Hello Lisa, I am very interested in this subject. I am a current cardiac patient, who at 48 under went Bypass Surgery last July 2001. I am currently interested in how your above article may also pertain to persons with a mental health diagnosis. I remember reading an article in regards to this type of discrimination a while back. Now I can't seem to find any info at all on the subject. That article may originally appeared in the Johns Hopkins web site. If I remember correctly, it focused on the Byass in Cardiac treatment for the mentally ill. If you have any info or thoughts on this subject I would appreciate hearing from you.
Michael J Pease <m-pease@msn.com>
- Wednesday, August 21, 2002 at 22:39:57 (EDT)
I am always so impressed with your health column, Lisa. The inequality in health care is alarming and needs addressing. Meanwhile this article shows us the necessity to demand access to the best diagnostic and preventative measures available.
Brenda Ross <brerfox@dowco.com>
- Sunday, August 11, 2002 at 15:39:21 (EDT)
What a thorough and well researched article - many thanks for this one, which could well save lives.

I have studied the list of symptoms of a heart attack, and will bear it in mind. Always good to be well prepared.

Cecile Hare <cecilehare@go.com>
- Tuesday, August 06, 2002 at 09:08:49 (EDT)

Back to the index page